Rashi (2:14) says that Moshe understood that the reason for
the harsh enslavement of Klal Yisroel was because Klal Yisroel spoke loshon harah
about each other. What is the middad
k’neged middah of lashon harah and slavery? What is the relationship between the lashan
harah and the lack of redemption? The
Sfas Emes points out in parshas Vayechi that Yaakov only had a thought of
revealing the katz when all the shevotim were assembled because it
is only through unity that geulah can be accomplished. He explains that’s why Moshe asked for
Shabbos to be the day of rest from the labor in Egypt for Shabbos unites
everyone (as it says in kegavna,) and that through unity we could achieve
geulah. Why is unity a prerequisite
for geulah? The Meshech Chochma
asks why does it say (3:7 ) רָאִ֛יתִי
אֶת־עֳנִ֥י עַמִּ֖י אֲשֶׁ֣ר בְּמִצְרָ֑יִם וְאֶת־צַֽעֲקָתָ֤ם שָׁמַ֨עְתִּי֙, it should say
צעקתה
in the singular for its talking about the
nation as one collective group?
He explains that it was the cry of every individual crying for the rest
of the nation that aroused mercy. It was
the crying for one’s neighbor’s pain that evoked heavenly mercy. It was the unity felt for other people that
merited the prayers to be accepted. Why
was this unity necessary for the prayers to be accepted?
The Lubavitcher Rebbe explains that the pre-Exodus Klal Yisroel and post-Exodus Klal Yisroel were very distinct. When coming down to Egypt they were a bunch of families bounded together by family relationship. However, they weren’t one unit, one nation. They were like the various Mongolian tribes pre-Genghis Khan. It was after the Exodus that we truly became Klal Yisroel. It was only then that all the families became one unit, one cohesive nation united in their service of God. This idea is explicit in the Book of Ezekiel chapter 16. Now we understand why unity was an imperative, a necessity, a must for geulah. For if we couldn’t unite, we couldn’t become one nation. It is indeed the bonding together, the shared pain, that would mold us together as one nation. It was the separation of people through lashon harah that would hold back the geulah and a prayer for your brothers’ pain that would bring it about (see LIkutay Sichos volume 31.)
However, we still need to understand that Rashi doesn’t say that
it was hatred amongst the children of Israel or a lack of unity that was the
cause of the terrible servitude, it was lashan harah? Why is it specifically the sin of loshon harah
more than any other display of terrible servitude? Chazal equate the sin of lashan harah with
the three cardinal sins that one must give up his/her life for. Why is lashan harah viewed in such an
extreme negative light? What’s the big
deal about saying a few bad words about someone? The Shem M'Shmuel in parshas
Metzora explains the severity of the sin of loshon harah is because
there is a unique quality to the force of speech. Most sins are done with the physical body,
they are acts that don’t directly destroy the spiritual wellbeing of the
person. Speech on the other hand, is not
a mere physical act but requires both the power of the physical and spiritual
dimensions of the person כידוע from Unklos who translates the nishmas chaim put into a person as the
ability to speak. Speech is the point of
unity between the physical and spiritual dimensions of the person. Loshon harah is a misuse of this
unification and directly deforms one’s spiritual well-being. (The same yesod can be used to explain
the severity of a false shevua. As on aside I merited to be at the siyum
of two friends who finished Tractate Shavous, for one of them it was a siyum
on all of nezikin, power to them for learning even masectos they
haven’t studied in yeshiva and may we merit to at least aspire to reach they’re
great heights.) This destruction of the
bond between the spiritual and physical being of a person on the micro-level is
reflected on the macro-level between each individual. Klal Yisroel is divided into many physical
bodies, however they are united by their neshomos which stem from one
general neshoma (see Tanya chapter 32.) Loshon harah severs a person’s
physical makeup from his/her spiritual inside and therefore, sever the great bond
that exists between us all. The Zohar (parshas
Vaerah) says that in Egypt the speech was in golus and Pesach is pe-sach,
פה סח - the mouth was redeemed. What does
this mean that speech was exiled, our entire body was in exile? Based upon what we have said we may suggest
that it is the speech, the harmonious existence both on the individual level and
on the national level that was the cause of golus and geulah.
Rashi (3:12) says
that was the זכות
we had to leave Egypt was kabbalos hatorah. It not the peshat that there was an Exodus
and then 50 days later mattan torah, it was part and parcel and indeed
the very reason for the Exodus. (The
Exodus was just the beginning of a process as we express lael peshach in
dayenu, ואכמ"ל.) That’s why we find there was an emphasis on
the unity of Klal Yisroel by kabbalas hatorah as Rashi says they
stood ki’eish eched belav echad. That
eish eched belav echad is part of the forging of a nation that accorded
as an account of the Exodus. The Shla
asks why was the Torah given only at Sinai and not to the Avos? He explains that the torah wasn’t given to
wise, holy, righteous individuals who recognized God, it was given to the
nation of Klal Yisroel. There had
to first be a Klal Yisroel and only after that can there be a kabbalos
hatorah (וזה יסוד
חשוב ביהדות שהרבה אין מבינים ואכמ"ל.) The eish echad feeling proved we were
one holistic nation united at the core, at that point we were ready to receive
the torah.
The lesson is obvious, may we merit to see the final geulah
speedily in our days, תיכף ומיד
ממש
I don't understand the answer of the lubavitcher rebbe. If I understand him correctly, he says that unity and nationhood are connected. אבל עדיין השאלה במקומה עומדת why is nationhood a prerequisite for גאולה?
ReplyDeleteAlso, you conclude that the lesson is obvious that unity is necessary for the final redemption. I don't understand. If the cause of the first redemption was because of unity it was because we were not yet a nation, but now we are a nation, so why the focus on unity. are you saying that by the lack of unity we revert to the non-nation tribal status (or some spiritual בחינה of that)?
ReplyDeleteBecause the geulah came about purely as a result of Hashem desiring the nation of Klal Yisroel. However, there had to be a nation, a unity. If people are saying lashan harah about each other, there is no unity.
ReplyDeleteIn regard to point two, חילי is from the kabbalah and chassidus that the galus and geualah of mitzraim serves as the example of where to learn from in our golus.
Anyway, its no chidush, כידוע the Beis Hamikdash was destroyed because of sinas chenum and will be rebuilt because of ahavas chenum.